How Should Families Split Cost Of Gifts?

Dear DoubleTake,
I have a question regarding gift giving. My sister-in-law likes to buy expensive presents for my parents and then asks me to share the expense. While I am grateful to have her do the shopping, I don't think the cost is being split fairly.
I say that everyone whose name appears on the gift should pay an equal share. However, she splits the cost 50-50. She and my brother pay half, and I alone pay half.
If we were all going out to dinner, I doubt that anyone would agree that this "per couple" share is rational. Are the rules of etiquette any different for a gift?

BETTY SAYS:

Giving gifts isn't about the money split. It's about giving an item if you feel like giving it.

I'm with you. Tell her, "I'm just going to do my own thing this year."

What she's pushing on you certainly isn't fair. If it were a group dinner date, you would pay for yourself and not two people. If you put money in on past gifts to your parents that she bought, your name should have been on those cards.

It's OK to say no to your sister-in-law's expectations. But prepare yourself for a fight if you do, because she won't be pleased.

Then again, time costs money. If you're a busy person, you may want to just cough up the cash if you think it would make your life easier. The holidays are a hectic time for families and in the stores, and not going to the mall for vanilla-scented candles may sound like a lovely idea to you.

EDDIE SAYS:

You're both right about how it works for dinner. But I say the situation changes for a gift, and it makes sense to split it based on the "family units" giving it. (That's too technical a term, but I'm sure you know what I mean.)

Look at it this way: If your brother and sister had two kids and wanted to put their names on the gift, you wouldn't say, "Ha! Now you have to pay four-fifths, suckers!"

At least, I hope not.

So, I think the way your sister-in-law wants to handle the money should work. But, as Betty says, this is easy enough. Mention to your sister you're not sure it's fair. Maybe she'll agree. Maybe not. Either way, you're a big boy who can look up online coupon codes as well as anyone else.

And, that way your mom gets two gifts, so she comes out ahead.

Do you need a second -- and third -- opinion about a problem in your life? Ask Double Take and you'll get two points of view: one from Eddie, a married family man in his early 30s, and one from Betty, a single woman in her 20s.

E-mail questions to doubletake@ibsys.com. A new column is published every other Tuesday.

To be considered for publication, please keep letters to fewer than 300 words. If you feel more background information is needed, consider adding it as a postscript. Because of the volume of the mail received, Eddie and Betty offer advice only to the letters that are chosen for publication.

Double Take writers are not trained psychologists and their responses should not be taken as a substitute for professional advice. Double Take reserves the right to edit submissions.