[an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]

Should Ignorance Be Tolerated? Nope

Dr. Laura's Fans And Foes Weigh In

Guess what? Dr. Laura's fans don't want to have lunch with me, either.

I should have expected it. I should have known that my inbox would overflow with venom and bitterness after last week's column, in which I criticized radio shrink Dr. Laura's remarks about homosexuality.

For the record: On her nationally syndicated radio show, the good doctor has compared homosexuality to incest. She's equated it with sadomasochism and bestiality, and she's labeled homsexuals as "deviants."

ProtestEarlier this week, both foes and fans of Dr. Laura demonstrated outside Paramount Studios in Los Angeles. Opponents want Paramount to cancel plans for a Dr. Laura TV show this fall; fans are anxious to see that show.

This week, I've learned -- among other things -- that I am a "sick lesbian" (this is going to come as a huge shock to my husband), a "twisted dullard" (whatever that means), a "deviant-sex advocate" and a "dysfunctional, deviant, devil-minded individual."

Got a strong stomach? Here's a sampling from my inbox this week:

Dr. LauraI guess you get the general idea: Anyone who believes that homosexuality is godless and evil is good; anyone who believes that gays have the right to live their lives the way biology impels them to is sick, twisted, deviant and damned.

I still fail to understand why so many people are so terribly anxious to instruct other people on the "correct" way to live their lives. What's the reason? If someone isn't directly causing you harm, why can't you -- as one writer put it -- live and let live?

But the reaction wasn't only negative. A lot of people checked in with their own objections to Dr. Laura's perspective:

Dr. LauraBut the e-mail that touched me the most came from a man whom we'll call Joe. He knows far better than I -- and much better than most of the Dr. Laura defenders who wrote to me -- what this all means. Here's what he wrote:

"A large stick with which to poke holes in 'Dr.' Laura's presumptions and personal opinions about gays and being curable by 'going straight' is the large but silent group of gay but married men out here in society, of which I am one.

"I have always been attracted to men, but 26-plus years ago married a woman, because that is what I felt was expected by society, my family, and my peers at the conservative Christian college I attended. I then attended and graduated from a liberal seminary and spent 13 years pastoring in various 'straight' churches.

"Well, I am STILL attracted to men. My continued exposure and life within straight culture (including two children) has done nothing to change my sexual orientation, not that I ever expected it would. I know better.

"Betsy, there are many, many like myself. We care about our wives and families, but can't help our natural inclinations. No matter how much we try to keep them in check, they always pop up sooner or later, and then we have to seek each other out (or other sympathetic but discreet gays), not just for the sexual release, but also for the rare opportunity to just be ourselves, let our 'hair down' and share a few precious hours with understanding friends.

"I do not consider myself deviant. What does appear deviant to me are those who subject us, and society at large, to the venom of hate and fear and anger, which says more about their inner selves and their personal/spiritual development (or lack thereof) than it does about any one else's.

"The 'True Path of Faith' does not condemn others for their difference, but rather embraces them as full members of the Human Family. Someday our disparate world cultures will finally realize that, but in the meantime we must patiently perservere.

"Your willingness to be a public mouthpiece and challenge to ignorance and fear is something for which I commend and thank you. Keep doing this good work. You will be rewarded for it inwardly and eternally for the positive contribution it makes to human growth and potential.

"Thanks for this opportunity to speak my piece (and peace too, I hope)."

  • Past Culture Shocked columns

    Note: Betsy's pop culture column, Culture Shocked, appears every Wednesday in our Entertainment section. She welcomes your questions and comments.

    Want to be notified by e-mail of the newest edition of Culture Shocked? Click here.

  • [an error occurred while processing this directive] [an error occurred while processing this directive]